Cash Back Mortgages – There’s no FREE Lunch!!

KellyHudsonMortgages • January 30, 2016

Cash Back Jan2016

You often see Cash Back Mortgage ads as a lure from the major banks offering cash back incentives on their Mortgage products. Cash back mortgages are becoming increasingly popular among borrowers, particularly those who have limited down payments.


So here’s some quick words of advice.  STAY AWAY FROM CASH BACK Mortgage offers!

What is a Cashback Mortgage? The deal is simple. Various lenders offer cash back programs, allowing a percentage of the property’s Mortgage value to be rebated to the borrower upon closing. The bank gives you cash up front to use however you want, except as the down payment .

The cashback on mortgage option can definitely help when it comes to paying closing costs, but borrowers should be aware that these products come with catches:

1) Higher interest rates The cost of the upfront cash is a much higher interest rate — usually about 2% higher than a Mortgage Broker negotiated rate. The higher interest rate is what pays for the cash the bank is “giving” you.

The homeowner would be pay a significantly higher amount of interest over the term of the mortgage. Homeowners need to crunch the numbers to calculate what’s more worthwhile:

  • Continue to rent and save for your down payment & closing costs
  • Overpay in interest, with the hopes of becoming a homeowner and eventually compensating for the higher interest rates with a possible increase value in the property.
Cash Back Mortgage Amount Mortgage Broker – Mortgage Amount Difference:
Mortgage Amount: $400,000.00 Mortgage Amount: $400,000.00  
Interest Rate: (%) 4.99% Interest Rate (%): 2.99% 2.00%
Amortization: 25 years (300 months) Amortization: 25 years (300 months)  
Term: 5 years Term: 5 years  
Payment Frequency: Monthly Payment Frequency: Monthly  
Compounded: Semi-annually Compounded: Semi-annually  
         
MORTGAGE SUMMARY (based on the above terms)
Payment Amount: $   2,324.14 Payment Amount: $   1,890.93 $ (433.21)
       Total Interest: $ 93,422.98     Total Interest: $55,288.49  
       Total Principal: $ 46,025.42     Total Principal: $48,167.13  
Total Payments: $139,448.40 Total Payments: $103,455.62 $(35,992.78)
Balance Remaining @ Maturity: $353,974.58 Balance Remaining @ Maturity: $341,832.69 $(12,141.89)
Difference       -$48,134.67

$48,000 difference over 5 years. It’s pretty clear why a Cash Back Mortgage is not a great deal for the consumer and why I discourage it’s use.

2) Clawback penalties: If you need to break your mortgage, whether to sell or refinance your home before your mortgage term is complete.… you have to pay the Penalty PLUS return the Cash Back portion to the bank. The Cash Back Penalty is sometimes prorated sometimes NOT depending on the lender, check the fine print of your contract.

3) Variable rates are not available: Another downside to cash back mortgages, is that they are not available for variable rates. For people who can tolerate fluctuating variable interest rates, variables have shown the potential over the long term to save you interest. That option is not available with a cash back mortgage.

4) Limited availability: Most lenders offering Cash Back Mortgages are looking for A+ borrowers with a solid credit profile, steady provable income, and typically 5% or more down payment.

5) The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) reiterated it doesn’t like the Cash Back Mortgage practice at all, recommending mortgage default insurers not underwrite loans that use cash back for a down payment.

READ the FINE PRINT – Many people miss the fine print on lender’s websites and in their mortgage contract. When a deal seems to be too good to be true, there is always a catch… There is NO Free lunch!

If you have any further questions about cashback mortgages or any other mortgage products, please call me at 604-312-5009

Kelly Hudson

Mortgage Expert

Mobile: 604-312-5009

Kelly@KellyHudsonMortgages.com

www.KellyHudsonMortgages.com


 

Kelly Hudson
MORTGAGE ARCHITECTS
RECENT POSTS 

By Kelly Hudson April 3, 2025
Are you debating whether it's smarter to rent or buy a home in Canada? It's a common question, and the answer depends on your personal situation. Both renting and buying have their pros and cons, but for most people, homeownership tends to offer substantial long-term benefits. Let’s explore both options clearly, so you can confidently decide what’s best for you. Advantages of Buying a Home 1. Personal Freedom and Customization Owning your home means having the freedom to personalize your living space. Dreaming of a bold paint colour or unique flooring? Go ahead—your home, your rules! 2. Building Equity and Wealth Each mortgage payment you make is an investment in yourself. Over time, your home typically appreciates in value, increasing your equity. This can become a significant asset that helps secure your financial future. 3. Stability and Security Owning offers peace of mind. You don’t need to worry about sudden rent hikes or eviction notices. Your home remains yours until you decide otherwise. 4. Long-Term Financial Benefits Homeownership acts as forced savings. Unlike renting, every mortgage payment moves you closer to outright ownership, building a financial foundation that can support you and your family for years to come. Challenges of Buying a Home 1. Upfront Costs Buying comes with significant initial costs, including a down payment, legal fees, home inspection, appraisal, moving expenses, etc. 2. Responsibility for Maintenance Owning a home means you're responsible for maintenance and repairs. This can sometimes be costly and inconvenient. 3. Reduced Flexibility Selling a home typically takes time, which can limit your flexibility if you need or want to relocate quickly. Advantages of Renting 1. Easy Mobility Renting offers flexibility to relocate easily, beneficial for frequent job changes or lifestyle adjustments. 2. Fewer Responsibilities Repairs and maintenance are generally your landlord’s responsibility, reducing stress and unexpected expenses. 3. Lower Initial Costs Renting typically requires just a security deposit and the first month's rent, making it easier financially at the start. Downsides of Renting  1. No Equity Building Rent payments do not contribute to your equity. Instead, you’re effectively paying your landlord’s mortgage, offering no long-term financial return. 2. Restrictions and Rules Landlords often impose limitations, such as no pets or restrictions on decorating, making it challenging to feel fully at home. 3. Instability and Uncertainty Renters may face sudden rent increases or eviction if the landlord decides to sell or repurpose the property, disrupting your life significantly.
By Kelly Hudson March 17, 2025
Since March 2022, mortgage rates in Canada have risen significantly, raising concerns for homeowners and potential buyers. But what drives these changes, and how do they impact your choice between fixed and variable mortgage rates? Let's simplify this important financial topic.